My little three-team Strat-O-Matic Old Timers' League is now taking shape! I started with position players. After a bit of finagling around the diamond -- for example, Deacon White was primarily a catcher but I'm using him at third base, where he played far fewer innings -- I ended up with between three and five Hall of Famers at each position. Ranking the players at each position was fairly easy. Looking at their game stats, I weighed offensive prowess, defensive abilities, and base running skills (super-duper important for nineteenth-century ball).
As for the pitchers, well, they're another story. I've got 14 of them, and although poring over Strat-O-Matic game stats confirms that, say, Cy Young is better than Amos Rusie, it's been challenging to rank them with any confidence. For one thing, even within the narrow span of nineteenth-century baseball, the earliest stars -- Al Spalding and Candy Cummings -- don't correlate well to their peers in the latter part of this era. The biggest question mark, however, is Rube Waddell, whose real-life dominance as a strikeout artist doesn't (in my estimation) come across in the game stats. I've tentatively broken them all up into staffs of five, five, and four pitchers (the team with innings-eaters Cy Young and Old Hoss Radbourn will have to make do with four), but it still feels like a shot in the dark. I'll draft my ranked position players next and add them to these teams, and then we'll see what we get.
As for the pitchers, well, they're another story. I've got 14 of them, and although poring over Strat-O-Matic game stats confirms that, say, Cy Young is better than Amos Rusie, it's been challenging to rank them with any confidence. For one thing, even within the narrow span of nineteenth-century baseball, the earliest stars -- Al Spalding and Candy Cummings -- don't correlate well to their peers in the latter part of this era. The biggest question mark, however, is Rube Waddell, whose real-life dominance as a strikeout artist doesn't (in my estimation) come across in the game stats. I've tentatively broken them all up into staffs of five, five, and four pitchers (the team with innings-eaters Cy Young and Old Hoss Radbourn will have to make do with four), but it still feels like a shot in the dark. I'll draft my ranked position players next and add them to these teams, and then we'll see what we get.
No comments:
Post a Comment