Series Preview

It will be the Canaries and Haymakers vying for the title -- a rematch of the Season 2 championship! Let's take a closer look at these two contenders.

Offense

• Haymakers: At 3.86 runs per game, the two-time defending champs are scoring almost a full run per game less than last season (4.7). Joe Kelley, Jesse Burkett, Cap Anson, and Sam Thompson are a fearsome foursome, but the lineup thins out quite a bit after that. The team's 10 home runs, however, is tied with the Season 2 Blue Legs for second-most by a team in a single season; Sam Thompson had three of those dingers.
• Canaries: This team smashed every offensive record in the books. Their 5.24 runs per game was the highest in league history, as were the 12 home runs they hit (George Davis collecting five of them). The Canaries also became the first team ever to eclipse 100 runs in a season and finished with 110. With Hugh Duffy, Ed Delahanty, Honus Wagner, et al, this team can flat-out rake.
• Advantage: Canaries

Defense

• Haymakers: Their defense was well behind the Canaries, but ahead of the Blue Legs. They're solid all around the infield aside from third (apologies to Deacon White), but the outfield is an adventure, to say the least. Bench player Elmer Flick is a capable late-inning defensive replacement for the outfield.
• Canaries: Honus Wagner struggled a bit at short (his four errors more than doubled his career total), but otherwise the team executed almost flawlessly in the field. I should note, however, that some less-than-elite fielders -- Monte Ward, Roger Connor, and George Davis in particular -- may have benefited from a bit of good luck, and although they didn't make lots of errors, their lack of range prevented them from getting to some balls that better fielders could have reached.
• Advantage: Canaries

Pitching

• Haymakers: The Haymakers allowed just 3.57 runs per game, the lowest in league history. Mickey Welch led the way with a 1.61 ERA and 5-1 record. He'll start Games 1 and 3, a prospect that ought to be terrifying the Canaries right about now. Jack Chesbro was 4-0 on the season and out-pitched Cy Young down the stretch to earn the Game 2 start. The Haymakers have power arms in Amos Rusie and Rube Waddell out of the pen, but expect Young to get the nod in high-leverage relief situations.
• Canaries: It was a great season for the Canaries staff, as they allowed 3.95 runs per game. Tim Keefe, last year's Pitcher MVP, had another solid year and will take the mound in the first and third games. Battle-tested Pud Galvin will start Game 2, but he'll have a short leash, with Kid Nichols waiting in the wings. Rube Foster and Joe McGinnity were both brilliant in relief, giving the Canaries a potential edge in late-game situations.
• Advantage: Haymakers

Prediction

They'll have to beat Mickey Welch at least once to do it, but I predict the Canaries will triumph by a margin of two games to one. They may have finished the regular season in second place yet again, but the Canaries are the better team.