Extra Innings

For the second time in four seasons, we've finished with a first-place tie. Prior to tonight's contest, the Canaries held a slim one-game lead over the Haymakers. A win would secure them the regular-season title, but the Canaries could must little offense against a masterful Happy Jack Chesbro. Despite their record-setting offense (most runs scored in a single season, most home runs hit in a regular season, etc.), the Canaries managed only a single run -- a solo shot by outfielder Hugh Duffy. Chesbro's mates managed to score two runs against ace Tim Keefe, allowing the Haymakers to walk away with a 2-1 win. 

Now what? We've known for the past couple of weeks that these teams will face each other in the best-of-three championship series, but first we need to figure out who gets home-field advantage. The teams will play a single tiebreaker game (which counts as part of the regular season) to determine first place. That team will be at home for Game 1 and Game 3. However, the scheduling presents an interesting quirk. In my (imaginary) calendar, there was a single off day between the end of the regular season and the beginning of the championship series. The tiebreaker game will be held on that day. As such, both teams will be forced to use at least one pitcher who will not be available in Game 1 of the playoffs. (To avoid tracking tedious information like pitcher fatigue, I have a simple "house rule" that a pitcher cannot appear in games on consecutive calendar days.) 

I'd have to say that the Haymakers are favored in this situation, owing to their impressive pitching depth. I'll do a full write-up previewing the series, but the short version is that the Haymakers have the arms and the Canaries don't. I haven't decided on who will start for the Canaries, but the Haymakers can run Cy Young out there for the tiebreaker. Not too shabby!

Davis! Davis! Davis!

Did I wake you up?

At precisely 9:14 pm Pacific, I shattered the silence of a pitch-dark desert night with a cry of "Davis! Davis! Davis!" What prompted such an exclamation? 

Tonight's contest involved the Haymakers hosting the Canaries in a game with major playoff implications. The Canaries were up 4-3 in the top of the sixth. With one out and nobody on, George Davis stepped to the plate. Facing the legendary Cy Young, Davis caught a fastball and pulled it deep to right. The Haymakers' Sam Thompson could only watch the ball -- and his own hopes for an MVP trophy -- disappear over the right-field fence. 

Davis had just hit his fifth home run of the season, breaking the single-season record set by Mike "King" Kelly in Season 1. Davis's blast was also his team's eleventh home run of the season. That too set a record, surpassing the Blue Legs' total of ten homers from Season 2.

So who ended up winning the game? Frankly, I'm done. I need to put Strat-O-Matic aside and finish this game tomorrow!

Season 4 Stars

We're coming down the home stretch in the fourth season of my nineteenth-century Strat-O-Matic baseball league. The Canaries and Haymakers are tied at 10-6 and will spend the last few games of the season jockeying for first place and, as a result, home-field advantage in the championship series. (I'm replacing the playoff format from previous seasons with a single best-of-three series between the first- and second-place teams.) 

It's been a great campaign with lots of memorable moments, but it looks like three men will stand out as the stars of Season 4. On the pitching side, the clear-cut MVP is Mickey Welch of the Haymakers, who might just finish the year with an ERA under 2.00 -- a feat that no starter has ever accomplished in this league. I can picture Welch's absolutely filthy screwball diving across the plate to freeze right-handers, while lefties swing and miss at its late-breaking action. After three seasons of maddening inconsistency, Welch has finally put it all together. Can he carry his mates to a third consecutive league title? He'll have help from right fielder Sam Thompson, who has bashed his way into the conversation for MVP of the position players. Thompson has been on quite a tear, and his three homers are second in the league to George Davis of the Canaries. Davis, meanwhile, has tied King Kelly's single-season home run record with four bombs (set all the way back in Season 1) and his superb all-around play (he hits for average, he's a fantastic base stealer, and he provides adequate defense at third) have put him in the driver's seat to win his first MVP trophy. I can't wait to see Welch and Davis square off against each other in the championship series. It's going to be epic!

1/95th Complete!

Well, we're now 1/95th of the way through Gloomhaven. It's a solid game! We definitely had our fair share of epic moments from the first scenario. Matthew's rogue-like hero turned invisible to one-shot the final boss and Nathaniel's warrior paired a class power (a "trample" effect that damages the foes in all the spaces you move through) with an item (boots that allow you to move extra spaces) to devastating effect. My favorite bit, however, is pictured below. In this sequence, my gnome-like hero (the gray mini in the lower left) used a grappling hook to snag an enemy and drag her across two traps, triggering them both and killing the foe in the process! 

Getting Our Gloom On

 Here's Nathaniel, ready to tackle our first combat in Gloomhaven...

The boys and I played through the first two tactical encounters today, and we'll try to wrap up the third and final fight of the first mission tomorrow. It's slow going, but we're learning!

So...

It's...it's a lot...

MVP Race

We're at the midpoint of Season 4 and I think it's safe to say that the Canaries are going to run away with the regular-season title, as they're currently sporting a 7-3 record and a whopping +26 run differential. What's less certain, however, is who will win the Positional MVP and Pitching MVP awards. Let's take a look at where we stand! I'll rank the candidates from least likely to most likely.

Pitching MVP

3. Joe McGinnity, Canaries. There are really only two candidates at this point, but I have to tip my hat to the Canaries' sidearm reliever, who has yet to yield a run. I think a relief pitcher has a better shot to win the award next year (the expansion team will result in a contraction of roster sizes, forcing relievers to throw more innings), but McGinnity could sneak up on us if he continues this run.

2. Tim Keefe, Canaries. Last year's winner continues to dominate, going 3-0 in four starts for the first-place team. His 2.91 ERA is second-best among starting pitchers.

1. Mickey Welch, Haymakers. The talented but enigmatic Welch has long been in the shadow of teammate Cy Young, but this year he's pitching like an ace. He's only 2-1 in four starts, but his 2.25 ERA leads all starters by a good margin.

Positional MVP

5. Deacon White, Haymakers. In a league consisting of nothing but Hall of Famers, White is no standout. This year, however, he's put together a fine campaign as a middle-of-the-order bat whose normally lousy defense at third base is (for now) league average.

4. Nap Lajoie, Blue Legs. His team might end up with the worst record and worst run differential in league history, but the Legs' captain and second baseman is a hit machine who leads the league in batting average.

3. Cap Anson, Haymakers. The Haymakers' first baseman won this award last year, and he's turning in another fine season. Although he committed his first fielding error ever, he's hit a pair of home runs and has propped up an offense that is scoring only 3.70 runs per game this year compared to 4.75 last year.

2. George Davis, Canaries. With a league-leading three home runs (and an all-time record of eight for his career), the Canaries' third baseman provides only average defense, but his power bat has sparked the Canaries to an impressive first half. Davis may well tie or break the single-season home run record (four), set by the Blue Legs' King Kelly in Season 1.

1. Ed Delahanty, Canaries. Delahanty plays wherever he's needed in the field (mainly in center) and has managed to avoid any defensive miscues while hitting two homers and leading the league in total bases. Although the Canaries have many offensive stars who are not included in this MVP ranking (Hugh Duffy, Honus Wagner, etc.), Delahanty is the main reason they're averaging 6.30 runs per game and are on pace to shatter the single-season record of 95 runs (in a 20-game season).

Dare We Take the Plunge?

As I had scheduled a little time off to spend with the boys during their last week of summer vacation, I thought it would be fun for us to get into a big, meaty new game. My first though was Blackstone Fortress, a cooperative dungeon-crawler set in the world of Warhammer 40k. Even if we didn't enjoy the game, we'd get a lot of use out of the minis, whether for 40k itself or for our futuristic Shattered Realm campaign. Alas, the supply chain gods did not smile upon us, as it appeared that the game would not arrive at our remote desert outpost until after I was back at work and the kids were back in school. 

Fallback plan? Gloomhaven. I've been reluctant to take the plunge despite the overwhelming number of great reviews. I'm not sure why. I do love coop board/strategy games, and this one features a legacy system (i.e., players' choices in and between scenarios impact how the game's narrative unfolds over course of the campaign), which should be right up my alley. Maybe I'll be more excited once I see the box -- it's quite a box, as I understand it.

Old Time Hockey!

I picked up NHL 20 on the cheap for our Xbox, and the boys and I are enjoying its handful of subtle enhancements over NHL 19. (Sadly, though, the legendary Doc Emrick doesn't do the play-by-play in this year's version of the game.) One thing that dawned on me is that the game is chock-full of opportunities to use players of the past. I'm now building a team of hockey heroes of yesteryear, focusing on the earliest players available. NHL 20 doesn't have the likes of Hod Stuart and Frank McGee (the lads I'm using in my pre-NHL Strat-O-Matic league), but it's certainly fun to zip around as Howie Morenz and Charlie Conacher. As for the team, I have enough forwards and an abundance of goaltenders, but the game doesn't offer many early defensemen. As such, I've used the create-a-player feature to build video game versions of Cyclone Taylor (an entirely pre-NHL player, but hands-down my favorite historical hockey star) and Eddie "Old-Time Hockey!" Shore to bolster the blueline. These guys will teach those young whippersnappers like Connor McDavid a thing or two about how the game is played!

I love baseball!

Really, I just love it! And what's not to love about a walk-off home run? Tonight, for the first time in the brief history of my nineteenth-century league, a game ended with the home team hitting a walk-off homer.

In a contest between the Blue Legs and the Haymakers, John Clarkson and Cy Young both pitched well, but the game was tied at 2 after the ninth. The tenth was scoreless, but in the top of the eleventh, the Haymakers' Amos Rusie gave up a run to put his team on the brink. Vic Willis, the Legs' closer, started off the bottom of the inning by giving up a sharply-hit double to Deacon White. With a man in scoring position and nobody out, the defending champs were in excellent position to get the tying run across the plate. Roger Bresnahan, however, had grander plans. The team's longtime catcher caught hold of Willis's offering and belted it out of the park. With that one swing, a 3-2 deficit turned into a 4-3 victory. 

The amazing thing is that the ball had only a 5% chance of leaving the park. I don't really have a favorite team in this league or a desire for any team to win any particular game (though I would like to see the Canaries get a championship at some point!), but I have to admit jumping up and down when that d20 roll landed on a "1" and Bresnahan ended the game in such dramatic fashion. A classic baseball moment!

Homer History

Amy and the boys were out of the house for a couple of hours, so I had a rare evening alone at home. What to do with myself? How about a baseball doubleheader?!

I had a ballgame on TV and Strat-O-Matic set up on the rug! The latter game was far more entertaining. In a dust-up between the Blue Legs and Canaries, Tim Keefe sent the first ten Legs down in order before Willie Keeler broke up his perfecto with a home run -- the first of Wee Willie's career. I thought that was going to be the game's most memorable moment until the bottom of the seventh, when George Davis crushed a two-run shot to put the Canaries up 8-2. Davis's blast was the sixth of his career, which moves him past King Kelly, Hugh Duffy, and Honus Wagner for first place on the all-time home-run list. After the Canaries secured the final out, I realized that another milestone was reached -- Tim Keefe tied Cy Young for the most career pitching victories with 13. 

Free RPG Day Is Here!

Huzzah! It's Free RPG Day, everyone! Enjoy, but please be safe out there.

Homerin' Honus

After three games, all three teams are tied at 1-1. We've seen a lot of offense thus far in this young season, highlighted by Canaries shortstop Honus Wagner clubbing his fifth career home run. That ties him with King Kelly, George Davis, and Hugh Duffy for the most homers in league history. With several players sitting on four dingers, we're likely to see this milestone reached again before the season ends.

Opening Day

At long last, baseball is back! The living players have their Opening Day tomorrow, but the dead ones -- the ones in my Strat-O-Matic league, anyway -- kicked off their fourth season of play tonight. In this contest, the two-time-defending-champion Haymakers visited the Canaries. After last year's collective whiff against Old Hoss Radbourn in the play-in game, the Canaries started the season hungry to claim their first-ever title. They jumped all over Cy Young in the first, and led 6-0 after four innings. Tim Keefe, the Season 3 Pitcher MVP, was cruising until Jesse Burkett and Cap Anson hit back-to-back homers to cut the Canaries' lead to 6-3. The champs continued to put pressure on Keefe, but he wiggled out of jam after jam. The key at-bat came in the top of the seventh, when pinch hitter Elmer Flick dug in with two on and one out. Keefe induced a weak grounder and the Haymakers failed to score. Rube Waddell relieved Young in the eighth and gave up a two-run homer to Roger Connor while still managing to rack up three strikeouts in the inning. When the Haymakers went down meekly in the ninth, the Canaries celebrated an 8-3 win. Season 4 is underway!

Free RPG Day

This Saturday is Free RPG Day! Click here to find a participating store near you!

Welcome, Resolutes!

I have my work cut out for me in creating player cards for the likes of George Wright and Frank Grant, but this exercise will allow me to field a fourth team in my nineteenth-century Strat-O-Matic Hall of Fame baseball league. I'm still a long way, however, from finalizing those game stats; in fact, I'll go ahead and play Season 4 with the original three teams and then add the expansion team for Season 5. I haven't worked out the details for how Wright, Grant, and the other new players will be added into the league or how the expansion draft will be conducted, but one thing I do know is the name of the fourth team. After considering many defunct teams of yesteryear -- the Mutuals, the Forest Citys (yes, that's the correct plural), the Atlantics, and even the Kekiongas -- I've landed on the Resolutes as the name of the new team.

A New Nine

What do Charlie Comiskey, Frank Grant, Clark Griffith, Ned Hanlon, Connie Mack, Wilbert Robinson, Sol White, George Wright, and Harry Wright all have in common? They're members of the Baseball Hall of Fame and are not included as playable characters in my Strat-O-Matic set because they were inducted in non-player categories. They were all players in the nineteenth century, however, and they're all bona fide Hall members, so they ought to be included in my league! And with nine more potential players (only one of whom, Griffith, is a pitcher), we would easily end up with enough guys to create a fourth team -- and without resorting to the use of early twentieth-century players such as Christy Matthewson or the middle infielders from "Baseball's Sad Lexicon".

Consequently, I've commenced the long, laborious, and most likely foolish attempt to build Strat-O-Matic stats for these gentlemen. To get started, I'm diving into Baseball Reference to get better acquainted with the site and how to find and manipulate the data I'll need to crunch. My task has some additional complexity because two players (Grant and White) were early Negro League stars for whom little data is available and two others (the Wright brothers -- no, not those Wright brothers!) date back to, literally, the dawn of professional baseball. Despite these challenges, I'm excited about exploring the numbers and bringing some new guys into my little fantasy league!

Hmm...

I could try to create player cards for Hall of Fame position players who were not included in the Hall of Fame game set because they were inducted into the Hall for other accomplishments (e.g., as managers, executives, etc.). I feel pretty confident that I could come up with reasonable baserunning and defensive stats, and by identifying statistically comparable offensive players, I could re-use existing hitting charts from other cards. And since we have plenty of pitchers already, I might just have a fourth team after all! I think I'll do a bit more research. I do happen to own a book that provides complete season-by-season stats for all major-league ballplayers for every season in the nineteenth century, so getting the raw data for the comparisons should be pretty straightforward.

So...Many...Pitchers...

My nineteenth-century baseball league is breezy and fun, without all the meticulous record-keeping that I do for its hockey equivalent. I can play through a nine-inning game in a half hour, and even though I almost never play multiple games in a single day, the season seems to fly by. Coming up on Season 4, I got to thinking about whether I could add a fourth team to the league, as I'm very much enjoying the process of creating an expansion team in my historical hockey league.

To add a new team, of course, I need more players. Currently, I'm using only players who debuted at the major-league level no later than 1899. Given that the Baseball Hall of Fame has inducted a rather limited number of players from professional baseball's earliest era, I have only enough players for three ball clubs (the Haymakers, the Canaries, and the Blue Legs), all of which have eight starting position players, two position players on the bench, and five pitchers. (And to get equal numbers on each team, I kinda had to fudge the career start date for one player.) However, we can get by with one bench player and four pitchers, so if I were to add an expansion team, I could immediately draw three position players and three pitchers from the existing teams without compromising their ability to put a full team on the field.

How do I get more players? Having exhausted the supply of Hall of Famers from the nineteenth century, I could push the timeline forward a bit into the early twentieth. Many scholars of baseball history mark 1903 as the beginning of the modern era (i.e., the National League, the American League, and the World Series played between their respective champions). What if I opened up to players whose careers started between 1900 and 1902? Would that three-season window give me enough players to add another team?

Well, Frank Chance would be able to welcome the remaining two-thirds of Tinker-to-Evers-to-Chance, but otherwise it's just pitchers. So many pitchers! Christy Mathewson, Eddie Plank, Addie Joss, Mordecai "Three Finger" Brown, Chief Bender! The problem, of course, is that I don't really need pitchers. I need position players, and they're in rather short supply. If I keep pushing the timeline forward, I'll end up with "modern" players like Ty Cobb, Tris Speaker, and such. They're baseball immortals every one, but the point of this league is to create a fantasy of nineteenth-century baseball, and these guys are decidedly twentieth century. So, for now at least, we'll have to put aside the dream of a baseball expansion team. Until then, it's Wagner-to-Ward-to-Chance! (Seriously, with an infield like that, how have the Canaries not won a championship yet?!)

Hot Stove Action

One of these days I need to get started with Season 4 of my nineteenth-century baseball league. Season 3 featured the Haymakers winning a record 13 games (in a 20-game season) with a +18 run differential on their way to a second consecutive championship. Basically, they dominated. On the flip side, the Blue Legs had an 8-12 record but with a -24 differential that indicated they were even worse than that .400 win percentage. Their 77 runs scored was the fewest ever for a 20-game season, and 23% of those runs came during a single 18-run garbage win. With only three teams in this league and a fixed number of players, how could I improve the woeful Blue Legs in a way that didn't feel like I was cheating the Haymakers or Canaries?

A couple of trades came to mind. The first was an exchange of talented but underperforming hurlers, with Kid Nichols going to the Canaries in exchange for Al Spalding. The Legs lost some games in the late innings last year, and Spalding will certainly help with their relief efforts. Nichols, meanwhile, gives the Canaries a valuable innings-eater and spot starter behind Tim Keefe and Pud Galvin. Next, the Legs and the Haymakers pulled off a shortstop swap that (in terms of cold, hard game stats) clearly favors the Blue Legs but (at least narratively) also makes sense for the Haymakers. The trade sent Hughie Jennings to the Legs in return for Bobby Wallace. Jennings is by far the better hitter and, in game terms, is defensively the equal of Wallace. Last season, however, Jennings got tagged for quite a few errors (entirely the result of bad luck), so the Haymakers have essentially run him out of town in favor of Wallace.

Yes, I've deliberately nerfed the Haymakers, but I can't have a 42-run difference between the top team and the bottom team in a league that has only three teams. Even with some positive regression to the mean, the Legs were looking at another tough season. The Canaries, meanwhile, don't really need any further tweaking, so I think I've got three relatively balanced teams ready to roll for Season 4!